A Mangled Matters Review: ‘What They Say’

Directed by Justin Romine


Clocking in at just over sixteen minutes, What They Say is not a feel good story.  It won’t make you smile and it certainly won’t help you have a good night’s sleep.  It’s a gory, unsettling tale that attacks you from start to finish.  The great Stephen King once said of his books, “..the sort of book I do.. should be a kind of personal assault.”

With What They Say, director Justin Romine certainly follows The King’s words.

The film follows a young woman (played by Heather Dorff, who also produced the film) tormented by inner demons.  Having lost her father at a young age, the woman struggles to maintain her sanity in a world overflowing with superficial facades and gossip mongers.  Pain, rage and depression are omnipresent themes in this short and I am hard pressed to name another actress who could have pulled off this role as fiercely as Dorff does.

When the woman begins to find solace in cutting herself, it’s a hard watch but so captivating, I found myself unable to look away.  Like her father before her, the woman succumbs to a very troubling epidemic that still runs rampant in our society today.

The film is visually beautiful- the shots are tight, the cinematography is crisp and vibrant.  The editing and visual effects by Radek Michalik are top notch.  Romine does a fantastic job of bringing such a heavy script to life.

Dorff and co-star Kelsey Zukowski constructed a solid script based on an original story that features excellent dialogue throughout from Dorff’s character, who serves as the film’s narrator.

As her demons begin to engulf her, there is a genuine scare in the film that made me jump in my seat.  Special effects provided by Joe Mistretta and Sean Jaster are excellent, if not disturbing to say the least.

What They Say is a true horror film- one that does not let up and will linger with you for a while after viewing it.  As the project begins making the film festival rounds, it comes as no surprise that it is already one of the most decorated, award-winning shorts of the year.


2 thoughts on “A Mangled Matters Review: ‘What They Say’

  1. Thank you for the very kind words regarding our little slice of Disturbia, USA. I would like to clarify that Heather Dorff and Kelsey Zukowski developed and constructed the script. I merely visually put life to an already amazing story. Thank you for the awesome review!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s